Essay Argument Stress Test skill for Claude and Codex
Finds the holes in your thesis before a marker does, with unsupported claims, ignored counterarguments and weak paragraphs ranked by mark cost.
Install it once and Claude or Codex runs it for you. When your request matches, your AI loads the skill, asks for anything it is missing, and works through the template itself. Prefer to fill it in by hand? See the full prompt template.
Download the skill (.zip) · View SKILL.md
When it is used
Use when a student wants a hostile read of an essay draft to expose weak arguments, unsupported claims and ignored counterarguments before submission. Do not use for proofreading grammar or rewriting the essay for the student. Related topics: Students, Writing, Academic.
What it will ask you for
- Essay question (free text, e.g. "the exact question as set")
- Draft (longer free text)
- Word limit (free text, e.g. "2000 words")
How it works
- Restate the central argument in one sentence, and report plainly if no single argument can be found.
- List each claim that lacks evidence, quoting the sentence so the student can find it.
- Name the strongest ignored counterargument and say which section should answer it.
- Flag every paragraph that only summarises sources, then rank all problems by likely mark cost, highest first.
What you get
A ranked list of problems, each with a quote from the draft and a one-line reason it costs marks, opening with the one-sentence restatement of the argument.
What it watches out for
- Rewriting passages for the student, which removes the thinking the essay is supposed to show.
- Ranking problems by order of appearance instead of by marks lost, so the big structural flaw gets buried.
- Judging the draft against a generic essay instead of the exact question set.
How to install
Claude.ai and the Claude desktop app
- Download the skill .zip.
- Open Settings, then Capabilities, and find Skills.
- Choose Upload skill and select the .zip.
- Ask Claude for help with the task. It loads the skill when your request matches.
Claude Code
- Download the skill .zip.
- Unzip it into ~/.claude/skills/ (or .claude/skills/ inside a project).
- Start a new session. Claude Code loads the skill when your request matches.
Codex
- Download the skill .zip.
- Unzip it into ~/.agents/skills/ (or .agents/skills/ inside a project).
- Codex picks it up on its own. Type $ and the skill name to use it, or just ask for the task.
Cursor
- Download the Cursor rule (.mdc).
- Save it in .cursor/rules/ inside your project.
- Cursor's agent applies the rule when your request matches its description.
AGENTS.md (Codex, Cursor, and other coding agents)
- Copy the AGENTS.md section.
- Paste it into AGENTS.md at the root of your repository, creating the file if needed.
- Coding agents that read AGENTS.md follow it when your request fits.