---
name: essay-argument-stress-test
description: "Finds the holes in your thesis before a marker does, with unsupported claims, ignored counterarguments and weak paragraphs ranked by mark cost. Use when a student wants a hostile read of an essay draft to expose weak arguments, unsupported claims and ignored counterarguments before submission. Do not use for proofreading grammar or rewriting the essay for the student. Related topics: Students, Writing, Academic."
---

# Essay Argument Stress Test

Finds the holes in your thesis before a marker does, with unsupported claims, ignored counterarguments and weak paragraphs ranked by mark cost.

## When to use

Use this skill when a student wants a hostile read of an essay draft to expose weak arguments, unsupported claims and ignored counterarguments before submission. Do not use it for proofreading grammar or rewriting the essay for the student.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Restate the central argument in one sentence, and report plainly if no single argument can be found.
3. List each claim that lacks evidence, quoting the sentence so the student can find it.
4. Name the strongest ignored counterargument and say which section should answer it.
5. Flag every paragraph that only summarises sources, then rank all problems by likely mark cost, highest first.

## Inputs

- **Essay question** (free text, e.g. "the exact question as set")
- **Draft** (longer free text)
- **Word limit** (free text, e.g. "2000 words")

## Output

A ranked list of problems, each with a quote from the draft and a one-line reason it costs marks, opening with the one-sentence restatement of the argument.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Essay Argument Stress Test

Act as the harshest reader on the marking panel and stress test my essay draft.

- Essay question: {{Essay question}}
- Draft: {{Draft}}
- Word limit: {{Word limit}}

Work through it in this order.

1. Restate my central argument in one sentence. If you cannot, say so first, because it means the essay does not have one yet.
2. List every claim I make that I have not supported with evidence.
3. Name the strongest counterargument I have ignored, and say where in the structure it should be addressed.
4. Point out any paragraph that summarises sources without advancing my argument.

Do not rewrite the essay. Give me the list of problems, ranked by how much each would cost me in marks, and note anything that does not answer the question as set or breaks the word limit.

## Pitfalls

- Rewriting passages for the student, which removes the thinking the essay is supposed to show.
- Ranking problems by order of appearance instead of by marks lost, so the big structural flaw gets buried.
- Judging the draft against a generic essay instead of the exact question set.
