---
name: syllabus-draft-reviewer
description: "Reviews a draft syllabus for gaps, weak alignment, and mismatched rigour, then returns strengths, weaknesses, and a prioritised list of fixes. Use when an instructor wants a second opinion on a draft syllabus before it goes to students or a curriculum committee. Do not use for drafting a new syllabus from scratch. Related topics: education, syllabus."
---

# Syllabus Draft Reviewer

Reviews a draft syllabus for gaps, weak alignment, and mismatched rigour, then returns strengths, weaknesses, and a prioritised list of fixes.

## When to use

Use this skill when an instructor wants a second opinion on a draft syllabus before it goes to students or a curriculum committee. Do not use it for drafting a new syllabus from scratch.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Map each learning objective to the weeks that teach it and the assessment that tests it.
3. Check pacing, reading load, and assessment spacing against the target rigour.
4. List strengths, citing the specific week or objective that works well.
5. List weaknesses, each tied to a specific week, objective, or reading.
6. Turn the weaknesses into recommendations and rank them into an action list from most to least critical.

## Inputs

- **Course title** (free text, e.g. "Introduction to Psychology")
- **Course description** (longer free text)
- **Learning objectives** (longer free text)
- **Assessment types** (choose any: Exam, Project, Quiz, Participation, Paper)
- **Weekly topics** (longer free text)
- **Reading list** (longer free text)
- **Target rigour** (choose one: Introductory, Intermediate, Advanced)

## Output

A markdown critique with Strengths, Weaknesses, Recommendations, and a Prioritised Action List ordered from most to least critical.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Syllabus Critique

Act as an academic reviewer who specialises in curriculum design. Examine the draft syllabus below and give a concise, actionable critique.

- Course title: {{Course title}}
- Course description: {{Course description}}
- Learning objectives: {{Learning objectives}}
- Assessment types: {{Assessment types}}
- Weekly topics: {{Weekly topics}}
- Reading list: {{Reading list}}
- Target rigour: {{Target rigour}}

Check alignment first: does each objective have topics that teach it and an assessment that tests it? Then check pacing, reading load, and whether the difficulty fits the target rigour. Look for missing weeks, uneven assessment spacing, and objectives that cannot be measured. Cite the specific week or objective in every point.

Return markdown with four sections: Strengths, Weaknesses, Recommendations, and Prioritised Action List. Use bullets, and order the action list from most to least critical.

## Pitfalls

- Giving generic feedback without naming the week or objective it applies to.
- Judging rigour by reading volume alone instead of how well the assessments test the objectives.
- Ranking cosmetic fixes above misalignment between objectives and assessments.
