---
name: sourdough-troubleshooting
description: "Diagnoses a flat, dense or gummy sourdough loaf by naming the one most likely cause and a runner-up, then gives a single change to test on the next bake. Use when a sourdough loaf came out flat, dense, gummy or with a gluey line and the baker wants to know which stage failed. Do not use for scaling a formula or planning a bake day schedule. Related topics: Food, Education, Research."
---

# Sourdough Troubleshooting

Diagnoses a flat, dense or gummy sourdough loaf by naming the one most likely cause and a runner-up, then gives a single change to test on the next bake.

## When to use

Use this skill when a sourdough loaf came out flat, dense, gummy or with a gluey line and the baker wants to know which stage failed. Do not use it for scaling a formula or planning a bake day schedule.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Restate the symptoms in crumb, crust and rise terms and map each to the stage that normally causes it.
3. Cross-check the stated timings, temperature and starter condition against those candidate stages.
4. Pick the single most likely cause and one runner-up, each with the reasoning that links it to the described loaf.
5. Prescribe one change for the next bake and describe the dough cue that shows the problem stage is right.

## Inputs

- **The result** (longer free text)
- **Recipe and timings** (longer free text)
- **Starter condition** (longer free text)
- **Kitchen temperature** (free text, e.g. "Roughly and whether it swings")
- **Shaping and baking setup** (longer free text)
- **Experience** (choose one: This is my first, A handful, Dozens, Usually fine but not this time)

## Output

The most likely cause and a runner-up, each with a short explanation, then one change to try and a description of how the dough should look and feel at the faulty stage.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Sourdough Loaf Diagnosis

Work through this as a diagnosis, not a list of everything that can go wrong with bread.

What came out of the oven:
- The result: {{The result}}

What I did:
- Recipe and timings: {{Recipe and timings}}
- Starter condition: {{Starter condition}}
- Kitchen temperature: {{Kitchen temperature}}
- Shaping and baking setup: {{Shaping and baking setup}}
- Experience: {{Experience}}

Match the symptoms to causes by stage: starter strength, bulk fermentation, shaping tension, proof, then bake. Name the single most likely cause and the runner-up, and explain how each one produces exactly the result described. Two candidates, not five.

Give one change for the next bake, so it is clear what fixed it. Describe what the dough should have looked and felt like at the stage that went wrong, since that is the judgement still to be learned.

## Pitfalls

- Listing every possible cause, which leaves the baker unable to tell what to change.
- Recommending several changes at once so the next bake teaches nothing.
- Blaming the oven when timings and starter condition point to fermentation.
