---
name: marking-assistant
description: "Marks a student response against your rubric with the justifying phrase for every band, then drafts feedback the student can act on in the next piece. Use when a teacher has student work and a rubric and needs criterion-by-criterion marks with feedback the student can act on. Do not use for grading without a rubric or detecting plagiarism or AI-written work. Related topics: Teachers, Feedback, Assessment."
---

# Marking Assistant

Marks a student response against your rubric with the justifying phrase for every band, then drafts feedback the student can act on in the next piece.

## When to use

Use this skill when a teacher has student work and a rubric and needs criterion-by-criterion marks with feedback the student can act on. Do not use it for grading without a rubric or detecting plagiarism or AI-written work.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Read the rubric and the response together, then assign a band to each criterion using only the rubric's own wording.
3. Quote the rubric phrase that justifies each band so the mark can be defended to a parent.
4. Pick two strengths and quote the student's own words for each.
5. Write one improvement target as an action for the next piece, not a diagnosis of this one.
6. Add the in-class sentence and, if the work sits near the next band, the single change that would lift it.

## Inputs

- **Subject** (free text, e.g. "Year 9 History")
- **Assignment type** (free text, e.g. "essay or lab report")
- **Year group** (free text, e.g. "Year 9")
- **Rubric** (longer free text)
- **Student response** (longer free text)
- **Marks available** (free text, e.g. "Total marks")
- **Include a model sentence or paragraph at the target band** (choose one: Yes, No)

## Output

A numbered response in five parts: bands with justifying phrases, two quoted strengths, one next-piece target, one spoken sentence, and the single lift change where relevant.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Marking Assistant

You are an experienced teacher marking student work. Work from my rubric, not your own standards.

- Subject: {{Subject}}
- Assignment type: {{Assignment type}}
- Year group: {{Year group}}
- Rubric: {{Rubric}}
- Student response: {{Student response}}
- Marks available: {{Marks available}}
- Include a model sentence or paragraph at the target band: {{Include a model sentence or paragraph at the target band}}

Return, in this order:

1. The band or mark for each criterion, with the phrase from my rubric that justifies it.
2. Two strengths, each quoting the student's own words back to them.
3. One improvement target, written as something to do on the next piece instead of a description of what went wrong here.
4. One sentence I can say to this student in class tomorrow.
5. If the piece sits close to the band above, name the single change that would get it there.

Pitch the feedback at a reading level the student can use, not one aimed at me. If the response is too short or too far off topic to mark against the rubric, say that instead of inventing a band. If a model sentence is requested, write it at the target band for the improvement target.

## Pitfalls

- Drifting to the AI's own idea of good writing when the rubric rewards something different.
- Praising in generalities like 'good effort' instead of quoting what the student wrote.
- Inventing a band for a response too short or off topic to assess.
