---
name: lecture-notes-outline-reviewer
description: "Gives an instructor a focused critique of a lecture outline: what works, where the gaps are, and concrete fixes for flow, depth, and assessment alignment. Use when an instructor has a draft lecture outline and wants a critique of its structure, depth, and alignment before teaching it. Do not use for creating a lecture outline from scratch or marking student work. Related topics: education, lecture."
---

# Lecture Notes Outline Reviewer

Gives an instructor a focused critique of a lecture outline: what works, where the gaps are, and concrete fixes for flow, depth, and assessment alignment.

## When to use

Use this skill when an instructor has a draft lecture outline and wants a critique of its structure, depth, and alignment before teaching it. Do not use it for creating a lecture outline from scratch or marking student work.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Read the entire outline once and state its apparent aim in one sentence so the review is judged against intent.
3. Assess each chosen focus area against what suits the stated academic level, noting evidence from the outline.
4. List weaknesses that each point to the exact outline item and explain the problem in a clause.
5. Attach one concrete, doable change to every weakness, such as a reorder, an example, or a check question.
6. Trim the review to the requested word count and confirm it ends with prioritised recommendations.

## Inputs

- **Lecture title** (free text, e.g. "Title of the lecture")
- **Subject area** (choose one: Physics, Chemistry, Biology, History, Literature, Computer Science, Economics, Philosophy)
- **Academic level** (choose one: High School, Undergraduate, Graduate, Professional)
- **Outline to review** (longer free text)
- **Feedback focus** (choose any: Content Accuracy, Logical Flow, Depth of Coverage, Engagement Strategies, Assessment Alignment)
- **Review length in words** (number from 100 to 1000)

## Output

A markdown review with Strengths, Weaknesses, and Recommendations sections of bullets, kept within the requested word count.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Lecture Notes Outline Reviewer

Review the lecture outline below and give the instructor actionable feedback.

- Lecture title: {{Lecture title}}
- Subject area: {{Subject area}}
- Academic level: {{Academic level}}
- Outline to review: {{Outline to review}}
- Feedback focus: {{Feedback focus}}
- Review length in words: {{Review length in words}}

Read the whole outline once before judging any part. Then assess only the focus areas chosen, against what is realistic for the academic level. For each weakness, quote or point to the exact item and say why it is a problem, then propose a specific change such as a reordering, a missing example, or a check question. Do not rewrite the outline. Balance the review by naming what already works so the instructor knows what to keep.

Return markdown with three sections titled Strengths, Weaknesses, and Recommendations, bullets under each, within the review length requested.

## Pitfalls

- Offering vague advice like 'add more depth' without naming which item lacks it.
- Judging against graduate expectations when the audience is high school, or the reverse.
- Rewriting the whole outline instead of reviewing it, which hides what the instructor should change.
