---
name: rent-or-buy-with-my-actual-numbers
description: "Compares renting and buying a home over your expected stay using your real numbers, with assumptions listed and the two conditions that would flip the answer. Use when someone deciding between renting and buying a home wants the comparison run on their own rent, price, deposit, and time horizon. Do not use for mortgage product selection or estimating what a property is worth. Related topics: Finance, Home, Planning."
---

# Rent or Buy, With My Actual Numbers

Compares renting and buying a home over your expected stay using your real numbers, with assumptions listed and the two conditions that would flip the answer.

## When to use

Use this skill when someone deciding between renting and buying a home wants the comparison run on their own rent, price, deposit, and time horizon. Do not use it for mortgage product selection or estimating what a property is worth.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. List the assumptions first: mortgage rate, price growth, rent increases, maintenance share, and investment return on the deposit.
3. Total the cost of renting over the expected stay, including the return the deposit could earn if invested.
4. Total the cost of buying over the same stay, including purchase fees, maintenance, interest, and selling costs.
5. State which option leans cheaper and by roughly how much over the stay.
6. Name the two conditions that would flip the answer, such as a rate change or a longer stay.

## Inputs

- **Where I live** (free text, e.g. "City or area")
- **Monthly rent for the kind of place I would want** (free text, e.g. "Rent amount")
- **Price of a similar place to buy** (free text, e.g. "Purchase price")
- **Deposit I have saved** (free text, e.g. "Deposit amount")
- **How long I expect to stay** (choose one: under 3 years, 3 to 5 years, 5 to 10 years, 10+ years)
- **My income is** (choose one: very stable, mostly stable, variable)
- **I want the maintenance responsibility** (choose one: Yes, No)

## Output

An assumptions list, a side-by-side total cost over the expected stay, a clear lean toward one option, and two conditions that would flip it.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Rent vs buy

I keep hearing both "rent is throwing money away" and "buying is overrated". Run the comparison with my real numbers instead of slogans.

- Where I live: {{Where I live}}
- Monthly rent for the kind of place I would want: {{Monthly rent for the kind of place I would want}}
- Price of a similar place to buy: {{Price of a similar place to buy}}
- Deposit I have saved: {{Deposit I have saved}}
- How long I expect to stay: {{How long I expect to stay}}
- My income is: {{My income is}}
- I want the maintenance responsibility: {{I want the maintenance responsibility}}

Compare the total cost over my expected stay, including the costs renters forget (buying fees, maintenance, selling costs) and the ones buyers forget (what the deposit could earn if invested instead). State your assumptions as a short list so I can challenge them: mortgage rate, price growth, rent increases, maintenance percentage, and investment return. Give a lean toward one option and the two conditions that would flip your answer. Mention that short stays and unstable income both favour renting.

## Pitfalls

- Ignoring buying and selling fees, which dominate the result on stays under five years.
- Treating the deposit as free money instead of counting its investment alternative.
- Hiding the assumptions, so the user cannot test the conclusion.
