---
name: rubric-self-check
description: "Marks your own draft against the rubric before you submit, showing the band, the deciding sentence and the smallest change to move up. Use when a student has a finished draft and the marking rubric and wants to know where it would score before submitting. Do not use for rewriting the draft or proofreading grammar. Related topics: Students, Academic, Writing."
---

# Rubric Self-Check

Marks your own draft against the rubric before you submit, showing the band, the deciding sentence and the smallest change to move up.

## When to use

Use this skill when a student has a finished draft and the marking rubric and wants to know where it would score before submitting. Do not use it for rewriting the draft or proofreading grammar.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Read the rubric and list each criterion with its band descriptors.
3. Place the draft in a band per criterion, taking the lower band when evidence is borderline.
4. Quote the deciding sentence or section for each band.
5. State the smallest change that moves each criterion up one band.
6. Give an overall estimate and the two changes with the largest gain for the least effort.

## Inputs

- **Rubric** (longer free text)
- **Draft** (longer free text)

## Output

A per-criterion list of band, deciding quote and smallest improvement, then an overall estimate and two priority changes.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Rubric Self-Check

Mark a draft against its rubric, strictly, as if it were the final submission.

- Rubric: {{Rubric}}
- Draft: {{Draft}}

For each criterion in the rubric give three things: the band the draft would land in, the sentence or section that decides it, and the smallest change that would move it up one band. Mark honestly: when evidence is borderline, choose the lower band and say why. Quote the draft briefly when pointing to the deciding text. Do not rewrite the draft, and do not praise beyond what the criteria reward.

End with an overall estimate and the two changes, across all criteria, that give the largest gain for the least work.

## Pitfalls

- Marking generously because the draft is the user's own, which hides the real gaps.
- Suggesting rewrites that go beyond the smallest change needed to move a band.
- Scoring against general quality instead of the wording of the rubric.
