---
name: startup-idea-validator
description: "Stress-tests a startup idea against problem urgency, market, differentiation and unit economics, and ends with a build, test further or drop verdict. Use when a founder has a startup idea and wants a critical scorecard of its weak points before spending time or money building it. Do not use for writing a pitch deck or a full business plan. Related topics: startup, product, idea."
---

# Startup Idea Validator

Stress-tests a startup idea against problem urgency, market, differentiation and unit economics, and ends with a build, test further or drop verdict.

## When to use

Use this skill when a founder has a startup idea and wants a critical scorecard of its weak points before spending time or money building it. Do not use it for writing a pitch deck or a full business plan.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Score each selected criterion from 1 to 5 using only evidence the founder supplied.
3. Mark criteria with no evidence as low and state what would raise them.
4. Identify the single riskiest assumption and design the cheapest two-week test for it.
5. Give the build, test further or drop verdict with a reason when requested.

## Inputs

- **Idea in two or three sentences** (longer free text)
- **Target customer** (free text, e.g. "Who specifically would pay")
- **Problem intensity** (choose one: Nice to have, Significant pain point, Urgent must-solve problem, Life-changing)
- **Existing solutions** (longer free text)
- **Market size estimate** (free text, e.g. "1B dollar market or local niche")
- **Evidence people will pay** (longer free text)
- **Ideas for reaching first customers** (longer free text)
- **Criteria to score** (choose any: Problem urgency, Market size, Founder-market fit, Competitive differentiation, Business model clarity, Technical feasibility, Regulatory concerns, Unit economics)
- **Add a Should I build this verdict** (choose one: Yes, No)

## Output

A scorecard table with a score and one-line evidence per criterion, the riskiest assumption with a two-week test, and an optional verdict of build, test further or drop.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Startup Idea Stress Test

Evaluate this idea critically before time and money go into it. Be the skeptical advisor, not a cheerleader.

- Idea in two or three sentences: {{Idea in two or three sentences}}
- Target customer: {{Target customer}}
- Problem intensity: {{Problem intensity}}
- Existing solutions: {{Existing solutions}}
- Market size estimate: {{Market size estimate}}
- Evidence people will pay: {{Evidence people will pay}}
- Ideas for reaching first customers: {{Ideas for reaching first customers}}
- Criteria to score: {{Criteria to score}}
- Add a Should I build this verdict: {{Add a Should I build this verdict}}

Score each chosen criterion from 1 to 5 with one sentence of evidence taken from my answers. Where I gave no evidence, score low and say what evidence would change the score. Pay special attention to willingness to pay, since interest is not demand. Identify the single riskiest assumption and propose the cheapest test for it within two weeks.

Return a scorecard table, the riskiest assumption with its test, and, if requested, a verdict of build, test further or drop with a short reason.

## Pitfalls

- Scoring on enthusiasm instead of evidence, which inflates every criterion.
- Treating a large total market as proof of demand for this product.
- Treating compliments from friends as willingness to pay.
