---
name: dissertation-topic-narrowing
description: "Takes the broad thing you are interested in and cuts it down to a dissertation question you can finish, with the scope, risks, and trade-offs of each option. Use when a student has a broad dissertation interest and a deadline and needs it narrowed to a feasible research question. Do not use for writing the literature review or drafting dissertation chapters. Related topics: Students, Research, Academic."
---

# Dissertation Topic Narrowing

Takes the broad thing you are interested in and cuts it down to a dissertation question you can finish, with the scope, risks, and trade-offs of each option.

## When to use

Use this skill when a student has a broad dissertation interest and a deadline and needs it narrowed to a feasible research question. Do not use it for writing the literature review or drafting dissertation chapters.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Restate the interest in one sentence and identify the discipline conventions that shape a valid question.
3. Draft four candidate questions ranging from safe to ambitious.
4. For each, state the data needed, its source, and the step most likely to overrun.
5. Check each against methods, deadline, and ethics timing, and flag any that fail.
6. Recommend one, name the cost of choosing the ambitious option, and list two actions for this week.

## Inputs

- **Broadly I am interested in** (longer free text)
- **Discipline** (free text, e.g. "human geography")
- **Length and deadline** (free text, e.g. "10000 words and submit in March")
- **Methods available to me** (choose any: Interviews, Survey, Archival sources, Existing datasets, Lab work, Textual analysis, Fieldwork)
- **Constraints** (longer free text)

## Output

A table of four questions with scope, data, riskiest step, and feasibility, then a recommendation paragraph and two next actions.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Dissertation Topic Narrowing

Turn a vague interest into a dissertation question that is doable in the time I have.

- Broadly I am interested in: {{Broadly I am interested in}}
- Discipline: {{Discipline}}
- Length and deadline: {{Length and deadline}}
- Methods available to me: {{Methods available to me}}
- Constraints: {{Constraints}}

Propose four candidate research questions at different levels of ambition, from safe to risky. For each, say what the scope commits me to: how much data, from where, and the step most likely to take longer than I expect. Check each question against my methods and constraints, and flag any that cannot realistically clear ethics approval in time. Then tell me which one you would pick given my deadline, and what I would have to give up to attempt the most ambitious one instead. Finish with the first two things to do this week.

## Pitfalls

- Offering questions too broad to answer in the word limit.
- Ignoring ethics approval lead time, which can consume half the schedule.
- Picking a question the available methods cannot answer.
