---
name: reading-assignment-digest
description: "Condenses an assigned reading into the author's claim, strongest evidence, weakest assumption and three discussion questions for seminar. Use when a student has a seminar on an assigned paper or chapter and little time to prepare discussion points. Do not use for writing a book report or citing sources for an essay. Related topics: Students, Research, Education."
---

# Reading Assignment Digest

Condenses an assigned reading into the author's claim, strongest evidence, weakest assumption and three discussion questions for seminar.

## When to use

Use this skill when a student has a seminar on an assigned paper or chapter and little time to prepare discussion points. Do not use it for writing a book report or citing sources for an essay.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Read the pasted text and state the core claim in two sentences.
3. Rank the evidence by how much of the argument rests on it.
4. Identify the assumption most open to attack in this field and explain the weakness.
5. Write three discussion questions covering logic, connection and challenge, each tied to a point in the text.

## Inputs

- **The reading** (longer free text)
- **Field** (free text, e.g. "political theory")

## Output

Four labelled parts: a two-sentence claim, ranked evidence, one vulnerable assumption, and three questions.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Reading Assignment Digest

Prepare a seminar-ready digest of an assigned reading.

- The reading: {{The reading}}
- Field: {{Field}}

Produce four parts. First, the author's core claim in two sentences. Second, the evidence the argument leans on hardest, ranked by how much weight it carries. Third, the assumption a critic in this field would attack first, with a sentence on why it is vulnerable. Fourth, three discussion questions that show close reading: one on the argument's logic, one on how it connects to another idea in the field, and one that challenges the conclusion. Cite section or page cues from the pasted text when available. Work only from the supplied material and say so if the text is too partial to judge the evidence.

## Pitfalls

- Summarising the whole reading instead of isolating the claim and its support.
- Writing questions that could be asked of any text, so they do not show close reading.
- Judging evidence quality from an abstract alone without saying the text was partial.
