---
name: history-essay-prompt-reviewer
description: "A concise critique of a history essay question that names its strengths, the ambiguities students will trip on, and concrete rewording to fix them. Use when a teacher has a draft history essay question and wants it checked for ambiguity, level fit, and alignment with the learning objective before use. Do not use for creating a new essay prompt or marking student essays. Related topics: education, history."
---

# History Essay Prompt Reviewer

A concise critique of a history essay question that names its strengths, the ambiguities students will trip on, and concrete rewording to fix them.

## When to use

Use this skill when a teacher has a draft history essay question and wants it checked for ambiguity, level fit, and alignment with the learning objective before use. Do not use it for creating a new essay prompt or marking student essays.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Read the prompt against the learning objective and decide whether answering it would show that objective.
3. Check the task word, scope, grade fit, and response length, quoting the exact words behind each problem.
4. Test whether every selected assessment criterion could actually be marked from a response.
5. List strengths first, then weaknesses, then revisions that include at least one reworded sentence.

## Inputs

- **Prompt text** (longer free text)
- **Historical period** (choose one: Ancient Egypt, Classical Greece, Roman Empire, Medieval Europe, Early Modern, 19th Century, 20th Century)
- **Grade level** (choose one: 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12)
- **Learning objective** (free text, e.g. "What students should demonstrate")
- **Desired response length in words** (number from 200 to 500)
- **Assessment criteria** (choose any: Argumentation, Use of sources, Chronology, Analysis, Writing mechanics)

## Output

A markdown section titled Review with three bullet lists named Strengths, Weaknesses, and Suggested Revisions, including at least one reworded sentence.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

Act as a curriculum specialist reviewing a history essay prompt before it goes to students.

- Prompt text: {{Prompt text}}
- Historical period: {{Historical period}}
- Grade level: {{Grade level}}
- Learning objective: {{Learning objective}}
- Desired response length in words: {{Desired response length in words}}
- Assessment criteria: {{Assessment criteria}}

Judge the prompt against the learning objective and the selected criteria: could a student meet the objective by answering it, and could each criterion be marked from the responses? Check the task word, the scope, the fit with the grade level, and whether the length is enough for the demand. Quote the exact words that cause an ambiguity. Be concise and specific, and do not rewrite the prompt unless asked beyond the revisions.

Return markdown under a heading called Review with three bullet lists: Strengths, Weaknesses, and Suggested Revisions. Give at least one reworded sentence in the revisions.

## Pitfalls

- Criticising style while missing that the prompt cannot demonstrate the learning objective.
- Vague feedback like make it clearer, instead of quoting the unclear phrase and fixing it.
- Ignoring the grade level and applying a university standard to a grade 7 prompt.
