---
name: math-word-problems-reviewer
description: "Constructive feedback on a student's answer to a word problem: what they got right, the misconception behind any error, and the next steps, with the correct solution on request. Use when a teacher has a student's written answer to a math word problem and needs feedback on correctness and reasoning. Do not use for solving a problem from scratch or creating practice problems. Related topics: education, math."
---

# Math Word Problems Reviewer

Constructive feedback on a student's answer to a word problem: what they got right, the misconception behind any error, and the next steps, with the correct solution on request.

## When to use

Use this skill when a teacher has a student's written answer to a math word problem and needs feedback on correctness and reasoning. Do not use it for solving a problem from scratch or creating practice problems.

## Workflow

1. Ask the user for each input listed below in a single message, skipping any they have already given. Where options are listed, offer them, but accept other answers too.
2. Solve the problem independently so the review rests on a verified answer.
3. Compare the student's work line by line and classify each error as a slip or a misconception.
4. Quote what the student did correctly for the Strengths section.
5. Write a hint or guiding question for every error that lets the student find it themselves.
6. Add a full step-by-step solution after the feedback only when it is switched on.

## Inputs

- **Problem statement** (longer free text)
- **Student answer** (longer free text)
- **Grade level** (choose one: 3rd grade, 4th grade, 5th grade, 6th grade, 7th grade, 8th grade)
- **Feedback focus** (choose any: Conceptual understanding, Computation, Units, Reasoning, Presentation)
- **Show correct solution** (choose one: Yes, No)

## Output

Markdown feedback with Strengths, Areas for improvement, and Next steps sections, followed by a step-by-step solution if requested.

## Prompt template

Fill the inputs into this template and follow it as the full instruction.

### Math Word Problems Reviewer

Review a student's response to a word problem and give feedback the teacher can pass on.

- Problem statement: {{Problem statement}}
- Student answer: {{Student answer}}
- Grade level: {{Grade level}}
- Feedback focus: {{Feedback focus}}
- Show correct solution: {{Show correct solution}}

Solve the problem yourself first. Compare the student's work with it line by line and decide whether any error is a slip such as an arithmetic mistake or a misconception about the idea; the feedback differs. Comment only on the chosen focus areas. Open with what the student did correctly, quoting it. For each error, name the likely misconception and give one question or hint that would lead the student to find it themselves. Write in language suited to the grade.

Return markdown with three sections: Strengths, Areas for improvement, and Next steps. If the correct solution is on, add a step-by-step solution after them.

## Pitfalls

- Marking a correct but unusual method as wrong because it differs from the expected one.
- Treating a careless arithmetic slip as a conceptual gap, which sends the student to relearn what they know.
- Revealing the full solution inside the hints, so the student never has to think.
